What to do after I-1631 failure?

You may have heard some economist last week mention the concept of “internalizing an externality.” The most obvious example of such wisdom (from society’s vantage point) is internalizing the cost of air pollution from our vehicles or the stack gases from power plants. That’s what Initiative 1631 was designed to accomplish: establish an opportunity to force our industries to internalize the polluting cost of carbon by paying a $15 fee per ton for its use. But then, that opportunity was rejected.

The rejection can be credited in large part to the carbon providers themselves. They want the cost of greenhouse gas emissions to remain external to their business model — rather, to let society continue to suffer the cost alone. They lobbied the voters, via political ads on TV and fliers in the mail to reject the fee; they encouraged a no-vote by pointing out that I-1631 would increase the price of gasoline (by 10 cents/gallon) and electricity (an additional penny per kW-hour) and thereby shift that cost to the American consumer. (True enough.)

So we have avoided that cost it seems and will travel down the old path a while longer. The climate change predictions may become more convincing, hurricanes may be more devastating, and more places like Paradise, California, may go up in smoke. But we, if lucky, will continue to dodge the cost of the carbon-based pollution that we’re causing.

I have a suggestion for what can be done with our savings: We’re told that most families will likely save $100 per year—at least $40 on gasoline and $60 on our electricity bill. Perhaps we should pass that money on to some young person. After all, they are more likely to need it.

— Ward Carson

More in Letters to the Editor

School and park districts should provide more access to track and field

Scott Harvey’s letter hits the nail on the head about the highly… Continue reading

Climate change: It is time to act

In Washington D.C. on Tuesday, Nov. 27, bipartisan federal legislation was introduced… Continue reading

Our government does not have clean hands

In addition to the First Amendment arguments that support Julian Assange’s innocence,… Continue reading

Private fireworks should be banned

With the recent horrific fires and loss of life and property in… Continue reading

Granny’s Attic supports many important services

After the meetings and discussions, it seems that there is a pretty… Continue reading

School district needs to tighten its belt

The recent Beachcomber article “School district officials tell legislators: Sustainability, solvency at… Continue reading

Island angels enhance life for seniors

How many of us truly realize what a treasure we have in… Continue reading

Billing for ambulance transport is unfair

This year, Vashon Island Fire Rescue (VIFR) got a gift from island… Continue reading

Gun owners need to use weapons safely

I am a Vietnam veteran (1968). Although I live within earshot of… Continue reading

What to do after I-1631 failure?

You may have heard some economist last week mention the concept of… Continue reading

Halloween fireworks display caused fear

I would never have thought I could be a fearful person. But… Continue reading

Donated funds strengthen schools

We appreciate your generous support.