News

Off course on the road to recovery

An orca from the J or K pod breaches off the coast of Vashon Island last fall. Four whales have gone missing from the J, K and L pods in the past year. - Kelly Keenan Photo
An orca from the J or K pod breaches off the coast of Vashon Island last fall. Four whales have gone missing from the J, K and L pods in the past year.
— image credit: Kelly Keenan Photo

By SCOTT RASMUSSEN

What only a few short years ago appeared to be an upswing in the population now seems like fleeting good fortune in the up-again, down-again saga of the Southern Resident killer whales.

With four members missing and presumed dead, the population has fallen to 80 animals, according to the Center for Whale Research, a San Juan Island organization that performs annual orca surveys. The population totaled 88 in 2010.

Center director Ken Balcomb, citing this year’s dismal return of Chinook salmon to the Fraser River, maintains that a combination of dwindling food supply and toxic materials accumulated in the blubber of the whales is largely to blame for the latest disappearances and drop in numbers. Without enough prey to satisfy nutritional needs, Balcomb said whales draw on blubber for fuel and toxins are then released into their circulatory systems in highly concentrated levels.

“All whales use blubber as sort of a freezer storage area,” he said. “The PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls) go from parts per billion to parts per million when they start drawing on the bank account of blubber, and just like in humans it affects the immune system, the nervous system, the reproductive system. It’s what happens when you have bad years for fish.”

The center, which maintains a census of the Southern Resident killer whales for the National Marine Fisheries Service, will list three whales missing in its 2013 survey, all from the L-pod. The three missing are: L-2, a female, estimated age of 53, L-26 a female, estimated age of 57, and L-79 a male born in 1989.

The census does not include J-8, a female whose age the center estimates at 80, and which appears to be the latest casualty.

Also known as “Spieden,” the 80-year-old female had shown telltale signs of declining health, shrinkage of tissues around the head — commonly referred to as “peanut head” — over the past two years, according to the center’s Erin Heydenreich, senior research assistant.

The Southern Residents consist of three pods, J, K and L. Called “residents” because they spend a majority of the year in the waters of the Salish Sea, the Southern Residents are considered endangered by the U.S. and Canada. Their population, believed to have been historically in the high 100s, was decimated by captures for marine parks, which ended in the 1970s, followed by pollution and declining salmon populations.

The whales’ population plummeted to 71 by 1973, climbed to 99 in 1995, then plummeted to 79 six years later. The population rebounded to 80 in 2002, 83 in 2003, 89 in 2005, and has seesawed around 88 since then. The whales were declared endangered by the U.S. and Canada by 2005.

Some orca advocates insist there’s greater concern for the long-term health of the population than just the decline in overall headcount.

Based on a study of the center’s survey, Orca Relief Citizens’ Alliance, a Friday Harbor nonprofit dedicated to orca recovery, cites a sharp decline in the number of breeding-age females and males, down 24 percent since 2004 and 26 percent since 2009, respectively. However, the next generation of breeding females, 3 to 15 years of age, has fallen even faster, down 39 percent since 2000, according to Orca Relief.

“Our new analysis suggests that the greatest danger to the population is much more serious than indicated by total headcount, as the breeding female population, today and tomorrow, plunges at an alarming rate,” Orca Relief Executive Director Bruce Stedman said in a press release. “We are concerned that if additional protective steps are not taken very soon, it could be too late for Puget Sound’s resident Orca.”

Orcas Relief notes that the number of juvenile males has increased 66 percent since 2009.

Faced with dwindling salmon runs, Orca Relief maintains the quickest remedy for the Southern Residents would be the creation of a protection zone off the west side of San Juan Island in which boats would be prohibited. Such a zone in one of the most popular spots in the region for whale watching would provide the whales with a buffer from whale-watch boats and a safe haven where they might rest and hunt more efficiently.

Meanwhile, Balcomb believes the answer to whales’ survival is simple, even if the equation is complicated: more fish.

“If we could keep lots of fish out there, even if they’re toxic, we wouldn’t have this problem with the Southern Residents heading down this road to extinction,” he said.

David Bain, a Seattle-based whale researcher who sits on the board of Sound Action, formerly Preserve Our Islands (POI), said that while there’s some disagreement among scientists over the factors contributing to the decline in the Puget Sound orca population, all seem to agree that lack of food caused by salmon harvesting and habitat destruction is the root of the problem.

Centuries ago, Bain noted, 1,000 to 2,000 Southern Residents frequented the Puget Sound. Now, he said, the population should grow to at least 500 to maintain a healthy level of genetic diversity.

The longer the population remains under 100 and whales breed within the small group, the more susceptible they become to diseases, especially as toxins impair the whales’ immune systems, he said.

Climate change is predicted to bring new organisms and possibly new diseases to local waters, while at the same time spurring ocean acidification, a phenomena that could diminish the remaining salmon population by 40 percent, he said.

“There is some urgency to get the numbers increasing on a steady, long-term basis,” he said.

Bain, who consulted POI in its fight against Glacier’s proposed mining operation on Maury Island, said some work has been done to boost salmon populations. He cited the removal of the Elwah River dams and local stream restoration projects — a start to opening up salmon habitat that has been blocked by development.

Still, he said, the whales have a lot working against them — including climate change — and actions taken now such as banning chemicals or removing culverts can take years to impact the whales.

“A lot of science is in place now, so we know what we ought to do,” he said. “The next phase is getting people motivated to actually do those things. Action so far has been pretty minimal.”

— Scott Rasmussen is the editor of the Journal of the San Juans. Natalie Martin contributed to this report.

 

Community Events, April 2014

Add an Event
We encourage an open exchange of ideas on this story's topic, but we ask you to follow our guidelines for respecting community standards. Personal attacks, inappropriate language, and off-topic comments may be removed, and comment privileges revoked, per our Terms of Use. Please see our FAQ if you have questions or concerns about using Facebook to comment.

Read the latest Green Edition

Browse the print edition page by page, including stories and ads.

Apr 16 edition online now. Browse the archives.