LETTER: Consider health concerns linked to artificial turf before voting

  • Tuesday, April 18, 2017 10:11am
  • Opinion

* Editor’s Note: Due to the media attention and unknowns about health risks associated with crumb rubber, the VISD board has already committed to not using crumb rubber and utilizing an alternative infill material.

Before voting on the school bond, please consider health concerns of the proposed artificial turf sports field. Actions were initiated first in the Pacific Northwest to protect children against carcinogenic materials linked to cases of lymphoma in football players.

Developed by Monsanto (the company that makes Roundup), artificial turf contains a cocktail of toxic chemicals including benzothiazole, carbon black and heavy metals. Mt. Sinai Children’s Environmental Health Center writes: “Exposures to chemicals present in crumb rubber at very high levels … known to cause birth defects, neurologic and developmental deficits, and some can even cause cancer. Children are particularly vulnerable.”

In 2009, a women’s soccer coach at the UW connected artificial turf and cancer after goalies were diagnosed with lymphoma, possibly from diving for balls onto crumb rubber and inhaling into their lungs. One soccer player in Tacoma died from lymphoma after spending half his life playing on artificial turf. Families suspect rubber specks that stick to skin, hair and clothing and get in players’ eyes, mouths and open wounds contain toxic substances that contribute to cancer in young athletes.

Financial ramifications:

1. Average life is 15 years. No cost advantage shown for artificial turf. Warranties are about eight years, when maintenance problems start. Do you want a 21-year tax lien on your home for products to be replaced before bond and interest is paid?

2. Maintenance cost has no benefit over grass. This chemical turf produces dead zones underneath inhibiting future biological grass restoration.

3. Many professional football players believe injuries are more frequent and severe on artificial turf.

Vote “no” on bonds to install artificial turf. Be cautious. Protect kids. Surveys show players prefer biological grass. Vashon can promote that teams play here on real turf — not fake from toxic chemicals.

— Lawrence Allen

More in Opinion

EDITORIAL: Take time to comment on proposed cleanup plans for Maury Island Natural Area

For years, the fight against Glacier Northwest’s efforts to expand its mining… Continue reading

COMMENTARY: Student response to gun safety movement has been disappointing

On April 20, 10 or fewer McMurray Middle School students walked out… Continue reading

LETTER: Outgoing director served seniors well

Senior Center Apple served seniors well Ava Apple steps down from the… Continue reading

EDITORIAL: Earth Day: Expect to be inspired at local celebration

This weekend, as is so often the case on Vashon, there is… Continue reading

COMMENTARY: Movements are made up of moments; let’s join together against sexual assault

Editor’s Note: April is Sexual Assault Awareness Month. In this column, the… Continue reading

COMMENTARY: Fireworks — It’s time to weigh the pleasure they provide against the damage they cause

Let’s talk about salmon and fireworks. Maury Island’s shore, which includes all… Continue reading

LETTER: Emphasis should be on potentially dangerous students

I have been reflecting on the gun violence question for some time.… Continue reading

LETTER: Basic human decency is at stake

The government not only spies on all of us but sometimes also… Continue reading

LETTER: After sun, island rain was welcome

I’m a third generation San Diegan, and I’m very much enjoying my… Continue reading

LETTER: NATO too interested in alliance with Turkey

On Jan. 20, the Turkish state invaded the Democratic Federation of Northern… Continue reading

LETTER: Dangerous drivers on island roadways

I have a question for the Vashon community. I have become painfully… Continue reading

LETTER: Israel belongs to Israelis, but what kind of nation will it be?

In response to Mr. Thalhofer’s letter on the Matisyahu concert (“Israel belongs… Continue reading