Big decisions for islanders this election season

One thing could be said before the results came in: A lot is at stake for islanders.

  • Wednesday, November 6, 2019 2:04pm
  • Opinion

This edition of The Beachcomber went to press just hours before ballots were due in this year’s election. While we were not able to report on the election’s outcome in this issue, one thing could be said before the results came in: A lot is at stake for islanders.

Flip through the King County Voters’ Pamphlet and there’s no shortage of information to chew on, but Vashon-Maury Island seems to be at a crossroads when it comes to its health care and parks.

That’s due to two measures both known as Proposition 1. One of them asks voters whether to replace the existing Vashon-Maury Island Park and Recreation District levy and the other if they want a hospital district.

These ballot measures come against the backdrop of uncertainties for island health care and parks.

Park District commissioners say without the levy, the district would go broke next year. The levy is essentially the lifeblood of the district, providing almost 80% of its funding. Without it, the district would burn through its cash reserves, commissioner Doug Ostrom has said in the past. Park District officials are hopeful islanders will vote for the $.45 levy, as a $.52 one was voted down by islanders earlier in the year.

The health care situation is not as black and white. If voters approve the creation of hospital district no. 5, a five-member board of commissioners would oversee the island’s health care needs and likely contract with a provider to maintain essential medical services (the district would not create a physical hospital).

But if this Proposition 1 does not pass, the island’s current primary care clinic, run by the Seattle-based nonprofit Neighborcare Health, would face an uncertain future. The organization has admitted that it is “challenged to fully support the cost of primary care operations,” feeding into many islanders’ fear that should Prop 1 not pass, the area would not have a primary medical clinic. Neighborcare, however, has said it has not made a decision on the future of the Vashon clinic beyond election day.

Come Nov. 7, the date of this Beachcomber’s edition, voters will likely know whether the island has a hospital district or not and if its parks will remain open. These decisions come after months of considering the possibility of higher property taxes or whether a board should be the final arbiter on health care matters for the island. A voters’ guide, as well as hard-working community members who sponsored forums on each of these matters, helped them decide.

The Beachcomber’s coverage on parks and health care this election season was meant to be informative, not supportive, of the ballot measures before voters. Throughout our coverage, however, we can’t help but think about the fact that this election seemed to be a real test for the island — a test that it can continue to be the place that it is for people who live here. Because depending on the outcome, islanders could have to consider their own Plan B.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Opinion

Troubling trend underscores need for making good decisions

Compared to many places, the number of island COVID-19 cases is low, but there was a surge in July.

Virtual Insanity

There is no magic bullet, but we need to figure out an equitable way for our children to learn.

School Will Be Different in Fall, but Expect Nothing Less

I’m feeling certain of one thing — that the details, when ultimately presented, will be worth the wait.

Antonia: A Maury to be Proud Of

We want to suggest that Maury Island be named for early astronomer Antonia Caetana Maury.

Our stories, on Vashon, will see us through

History has its eyes on us, and thanks to Vashon, we at The Beachcomber are not throwing our shot.

Should we rename Maury Island?

Whatever you think we should do, we need to build a census about what is the appropriate action.

What’s your story?

The most important question for me is, “What will I tell my granddaughter when she grows up?”

What it means to defund the police

To many of the people I work with, it means shrinking this whole system.

Four reasons Vashon needs a pedestrian main street

We need to change our town this year. Here’s why.

A parade on Vashon showed true patriotism

The island’s July 4 festivities made visible those working on behalf of our community.

Up to us all to dismantle white supremacy

We need everyone to take responsibility for dismantling the system of white supremacy in our country