Reasons to vote against a hospital district

Several considerations should be made.

Before you vote on the proposed hospital district (Prop 1) please consider these comments. I don’t mind paying taxes but I do want the taxes I pay to be used wisely.

1. Prop 1 is advertised as an all or nothing proposition — either we vote for it or the island will be barren of medical services. I do not believe this is true.

2. The most likely provider/partner or manager of services will be Neighborcare Health. Is this what you want?

3. At this point, we don’t know what services we will get from the additional tax burden, even if the current services will be provided.

4. Consultants may say, “offer lots and then you can produce little.”

5. Any procedures that require specialized equipment or expertise will be referred off the island.

6. For low-income seniors, taxes can be deferred, not necessarily eliminated.

7. It was stated that going off the island for medical services for some is an inconvenience. Going off the island for anything is an inconvenience. The fact remains that we do live on an island and have chosen to do so for a number of individual and unique reasons.

8. Orcas Island and Lopez Island were given as examples of other islands that have hospital districts. Compare the ferry times and ferry runs of these islands to Vashon. This is not a fair comparison.

9. Many of the commissioners stated they will defer compensation. This will not last forever.

10. Trust in the process should be earned, not given.

It is better to wait and determine what medical needs the island has through the many diverse and unique voices of Vashon ahead of time, evaluate the cost for those determined needs and then develop a funding plan that meets those needs.

— Steve Nourse

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Opinion

A parade on Vashon showed true patriotism

The island’s July 4 festivities made visible those working on behalf of our community.

What it means to defund the police

To many of the people I work with, it means shrinking this whole system.

What’s your story?

The most important question for me is, “What will I tell my granddaughter when she grows up?”

Four reasons Vashon needs a pedestrian main street

We need to change our town this year. Here’s why.

Watching unity in action on island

Stories appearing in this issue of The Beachcomber seemed to be centered around the theme of unity.

Introducing the Whole Vashon Catalog

We hope this will launch a groundswell of strength, creativity and the will to save our Earth.

Up to us all to dismantle white supremacy

We need everyone to take responsibility for dismantling the system of white supremacy in our country

Pandemic, Prejudice, and Pentecost

We are in a Pentecost moment in our society — a moment of crisis and potential for profound change.

In watershed times, the Class of 2020 can do anything

Perhaps it is the rest of us who need to challenge ourselves to be as good as they are.

Trump not acting presidential in crisis

This is where the country is right now. Is this where we want to go? Is this who we are?

Mindfulness needed in writing

A reader reacts to a reference made to King Kong in a recent article.