In Divided Times, Find a Good Person To Disagree With

Part of the reason we’re afraid to talk with each other today is we don’t want to risk being changed.

  • Saturday, February 6, 2021 4:07pm
  • Opinion
Mike Ivaska

Mike Ivaska

Somewhere in his writings, the great missionary thinker Lesslie Newbigin wrote that to enter into dialogue with a person of a different faith is as much to risk being converted by them as it is to potentially convert them.

To actually engage with someone of a different faith is to put one’s own faith, so to speak, at risk. “Mission changes not only the world but also the church,” Newbigin wrote in “The Open Secret.” It was a risk Bishop Newbigin wanted Christians to take because a missionary church is an open church. And it’s a risk I can understand avoiding like the plague.

In our hostile and divided time, the last thing anyone wants to do is risk being converted — politically, socially, or religiously. To paraphrase a meme I saw years ago on Facebook, “I don’t call out people’s ignorance because I think they will change. I call out their ignorance for the sake of who’s watching.”

In other words, the time for dialogue is over. The time for confrontation has begun. Those who disagree (with my politics, my social vision, my beliefs) are irredeemably lost. The only thing left to do is attack. Perhaps I will change some bystander’s mind in the process.

Part of the reason we’re afraid to talk with each other today is we don’t want to risk being changed. People with whom we are already aligned are free to pull us further in directions we want to go, but people with a diametrically opposite viewpoint are anathema. We may say we are open to talking with them, but that just means we are open to being heard. Or it may mean we are open to lighthearted, meaningless small talk.

But while being heard by others does matter, and while not every conversation needs to be heavy, I believe our collective inability to listen — to be genuinely interested in those who aren’t like us, who don’t think like us — lies at the heart of our cultural pain.

As an evangelical Christian pastor, one of the most challenging and beneficial friendships I’ve developed is with Koshin Christopher Cain, director of the Puget Sound Zen Center here on Vashon.

Interfaith friendships are a challenge for people like me because my faith teaches there’s only one way to God (becoming a disciple of Jesus and being reconciled to God through him). From an evangelical perspective, interfaith dialogue tends to come in two forms — either we pretend we are all saying the same thing in different words (which we all know isn’t true), or we treat one another as objects for argument and conversion.

But to be friends with someone who simply sees the world not as I do is refreshing, even as it is challenging. In a culture obsessed with argument, subtext, and power, it’s refreshing to ask questions and listen, to openly admit commonalities and differences, all in the context of collegiality (we both lead religious communities) and friendship.

As Koshin has said about our culture today, “If we see things differently, we feel we shouldn’t get close to each other.” But I, for one, am glad he and I have risked being friends. Such a friendship has converted me in many ways, I’ll admit, even as I remain a loyal follower of Jesus. And our friendship, I think, has converted him a bit, too. Part of me has to wonder, as I look out on our divided and angry culture: if an evangelical pastor and a Zen Buddhist teacher can find friendship, maybe some of the rest of us can, too.

Mike Ivaska is the pastor of the evangelical congregation of Vashon Island Community Church.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Opinion

There’s Work To Be Done On Vashon

True racial equity should be a daily practice in our town and in our schools.

Moving Forward, Into Community, at VCC

I speak for every staff person at VCC when I say that we are pent up with creative ideas.

Midwifery, the Original Way We Become Human

Safe, accessible and high-quality homebirth is an option on Vashon once again.

It’s On Us All to Open Schools Safely

It is a choice made for our entire community, which could bring both great rewards and great risks.

What Will It Take To Make Us Change?

There seems to be an “us and them” mentality for every issue.

In Divided Times, Find a Good Person To Disagree With

Part of the reason we’re afraid to talk with each other today is we don’t want to risk being changed.

True Friendships Can Form Across a Chasm of Beliefs

The more we steer away from people based on boxes we’ve put them in, the more isolated we become.

To Find Common Ground, Practice Respect

Such character will help bring true unity to our small isle, and our nation, in these hard times.

Right Now Is Not the Time To Re-Open Schools

Heartbreaking as it is to say this, how is it sensible to re-open now?

A Stay-at-Home Son Ponders the Pandemic

I never expected to be back on Vashon in the year after my graduation, let alone living at home.

Our Own Year of Magical Thinking

Let’s do a little thought experiment to put all of the chaos of the last year into perspective.

After Capitol Unrest, Island Remains “Beloved Community”

I had a visceral reaction to the violent and riotous storming of the Capitol Building.