While working on an article about a month ago regarding renting on the island, we posted a request for renters’ stories in the Vashonites Facebook group.

We received a small number of responses by the deadline, but the question itself spurred an interesting online exchange among islanders that has ebbed and flowed in the weeks since then, garnering more than 200 comments.

Many islanders have been grappling with the housing issue for some time, and as we have said before, we would like to see a community conversation — followed by concrete action — dedicated to island housing and related issues. It is possible social media could play an important role in that conversation. Regardless, many of the comments in that long thread are worth further attention, if only to understand what various islanders are thinking about this complex issue.

One of the thoughts expressed is to increase minimum wages on the island to at least $20 per hour. Is this realistic? Or even possible? Many business owners no doubt would say no. And yet, we cannot expect to import our work force from off-island. And what would the fabric of the island be without people across the economic spectrum? The topic of wages would be excellent to explore in person with those who work on the island and the islanders who employ them. But would anyone attend such a meeting? It is far easier to post on Facebook than talk face to face. In the mean time, people interested in this topic might want to join Vashon and Maury Islanders for a Living Wage on — of course — Facebook.

What about vacation rentals? Some have suggested they are part of the problem, as property owners turn to that option instead of long-term rentals. Can we begrudge those property owners for making the best choices for themselves? Conversely, should we limit the number of vacation rentals allowed? Is there even solid, current data on how much this contributes to the problem on Vashon?

And, of course, taxes came into the Facebook conversation too. The recent spike in property taxes has meant sizeable increases this year for many. But what about a state income tax? Could that be beneficial in the long run? And what are the realistic odds of Washington establishing one?

The questions are countless and easy answers elusive. But the island is at a crossroads, and this question — if there are steps that we can take to ensure that islanders from several economic groups can continue to afford to live here — is vital to answer. Soon.

Who will lead? Who will follow? With no local government, it is up to us to act.