LETTER: Treatment without parents present requires thought

  • Tuesday, September 12, 2017 10:33am
  • Opinion

On Aug. 30, a front-page article in The Beachcomber reminded us of the new health center operating on our high school campus (“School health clinic opens next month, Aug. 30). Parents were encouraged to sign and return legal consent forms promptly.

Do you believe parental involvement contributes to better diagnosis and health care outcomes? Or, can your 7- or 9-year-old adequately explain the details of his upset stomach or what patterns surround her asthma attacks? Do they know the details about Aunt Lydia’s diabetes or Tio Manuel’s heart condition? Do they even speak English fluently?

Imagine a doctor meets 10-year-old Maria for the first time. She exhibits asthma symptoms. Can the doctor adequately evaluate her without parental input? What if Maria doesn’t have asthma?

Our doctor gave my son a diagnosis of exercise-induced asthma at the age of 7. Then, he tried to hand me an inhaler. I refused, saying: “My son doesn’t have asthma. This is a symptom. We need to find the real problem.”

In lieu of the standard pharmaceutical options, we chose allergy testing and corresponding changes in his diet. Within two weeks, asthma symptoms dissipated. After four months he was back to eating most foods, and the “asthma symptoms” have never returned. He’s now touring the Olympic Peninsula on his bike.

You shouldn’t be asked to make this decision during the back-to-school craziness. You can put these legal documents on the back burner and wait a few days, a couple weeks, maybe even a month or two. Do your children want to see the doctor alone while at school? Is your family medical background complex? Or, is it perfect for you? Maybe you love this idea.

Whatever your final decision, you deserve to sign on the dotted line, with confidence (or not).

— March Twisdale

More in Opinion

EDITORIAL: Despite challenges, special events benefit island

Last weekend’s sheepdog trials kick off the summer months, when a handful… Continue reading

COMMENTARY: Separation of children from parents must end

In late April, Attorney General Jeff Sessions ordered his U.S. attorneys to… Continue reading

COMMENTARY: Understand Community Council’s history before bringing it back

Thanks to The Beachcomber for suggesting a revival of the community council,… Continue reading

LETTER: Radio broadcast was valuable community service

Last week’s King County Annual Town Hall meeting was broadcast on Voice… Continue reading

LETTER: Board member demonstrates unprofessional behavior

After reading about the recent Vashon Park District meeting to discuss staff… Continue reading

LETTER: Primary system not representative

Does our top-two primary in Washington State give us what we want?… Continue reading

Signature of registered voter is a coveted commodity

The competitive nature of the initiative and referendum season now peaking in Washington.

LETTER: More respect should have been shown to longtime doctor

I know I join thousands of Vashonites in expressing sadness about the… Continue reading

LETTER: Changes to the paper dumbed it down

It was distressing to see the graphic and other changes in this… Continue reading

Most Read