Don’t conflate immigration, over-population

I agree with Jeff Schnelz that population growth is an important issue that needs to be addressed (“We are stifling ourselves with growth,” Jan. 31). However, it was not the focus of the event in question. The Bridges not Barriers event offered a first-hand account by human rights attorney Molly Matter about abuses — primarily affecting children — perpetrated at our southern border. The question and answer period was dedicated to action steps — ways we could turn our outrage toward improving the lives of families fleeing violence and poverty in Central America.

It may not have been Mr. Schnelz’ intent, but his question seemed to conflate overpopulation with immigration. Those of us involved in anti-racist work have become aware that people of color have long suffered from accusations of causing overpopulation. Women and men of color have been targeted for forced sterilization through the 20th century. Negative stereotypes of African American teenage mothers and “welfare queens” have bombarded us. Racial overtones in the current administration’s characterization of asylum-seekers are impossible to ignore.

We need to do many things at once — immigration reform and population growth among them. I plan to push back on this administration and demand they expand access to family planning. The current policy of the Department of Health and Human Services is to expand the number of employers who can claim moral objection in order to opt out of providing no-cost contraception. This will not help efforts at population reduction. Women of all ethnicities tend to have fewer pregnancies when they have meaningful work and good healthcare for their children.

Long-standing U.S. policies in Central America are a major part of what’s driving people to seek asylum here. Our history of arming violent dictators has been under-reported in our media. As citizens, we can influence these policies with our vote and through activism. I feel fortunate to be able to help but, in fact, it’s my responsibility to do so.

—Jessica Lisovsky

More in Letters to the Editor

We should appreciate every family’s immigration

So many are out there still struggling to find a better home like your ancestors’ and mine.

Donations will be matched for Island Center Homes

Vashon HouseHold has a unique opportunity for islanders to support a new affordable housing project.

Not all slices are created equal

I will only purchase pizza from the two places that are run by locals who I know and love.

8 of 9 candidates say they will forgo pay, insurance

Some voters have expressed concern over how property taxes would be used to compensate commissioners

Vote ‘yes’ for island parks

A recent letter to the editor implied that all of the island’s parks were in the King County system.

Affordable housing: Community-based solution is possible

With respect, a few quick clarifications in response to Gordon Quinlan’s letter… Continue reading

Unofficial mayor candidate: Thanks for supporting VIPP

This letter is to thank all the individuals and businesses that supported… Continue reading

New housing development will provide decent, peaceful housing

Mr. Lukoskie’s concept of 40 affordable cottages scattered around the island is… Continue reading

County park levy will help Vashon

The popularity of trails is exploding on Vashon and across the country.… Continue reading

Most Read