LETTER: Primary system not representative

Does our top-two primary in Washington State give us what we want? We want to vote in an open primary with the right to vote for the person instead of the party. We also want majority rule to give us a representative democracy. Our “top-two primary” satisfies the first wish but not the second.

We now have a problem with our 34th Legislative District Senate primary on Aug. 7. Our current senator, Sharon Nelson, is not running for re-election. Eleven candidates have filed to run for Sharon’s seat: seven Democrats, two Republicans, one Independent and one “no party” candidate.

In 2016 Andrew Pilloud (Republican) received 20.25 percent of the vote to 79.75 percent for Joe Fitzgibbon (Democrat) in the race for 34th District House, Position 2.

In our current senate race, if the two Republicans each receive 10 percent of the vote, the remaining 80 percent will be split among the other nine candidates. This is an average of 8.89 percent for each of those nine candidates (not enough to win if they closely divide the vote). The 34th District — one of the most progressive districts in the state — could put two Republicans in the general election and no Democrats. Is this majority rule democracy?

There are at least three ways to combat the negative effects of this undemocratic plurality “top two” primary.

1) Find two or three Democrats willing to drop out of the race.

2) Ask the 34th District Democrats to endorse no more than two or three Democrats — also ask other progressive organizations to endorse the same Democrats.

3) Work for a future with an open, majority-rule election primary, such as ranked-choice voting (like Maine). With ranked-choice voting, no gaming of the election system is possible, and this aberration could never happen. See FairVote.org.

— Melvin Mackey

More in Letters to the Editor

View population concerns through proper framework

A few weeks ago, I was honored to give a talk at… Continue reading

Don’t conflate immigration, over-population

I agree with Jeff Schnelz that population growth is an important issue… Continue reading

Forest Stewards should be able to relocate on island

It will be a real shame if the Vashon Forest Stewards’ mill… Continue reading

Local mural needs to addressed

The first time I saw the cartoonish, racist mural of a black… Continue reading

We are stifling ourselves with growth

I went to the immigrant rights meeting at the Land Trust on… Continue reading

Jesus understood truth, love

I enjoyed Michael Shook’s response to my letter (“Christianity: Love is most… Continue reading

Islanders were generous with food bank over holidays

Vashon opened its heart — and its pocketbook — to the food… Continue reading

In between the light and the dark

The source for solutions to climate change is love.

We need power that carbon provides

Giving money to politicians in Olympia is not going to solve the problem of climate change.

Resolve to change the world, a bit

With the new year upon us and so many questions about the… Continue reading

Newspaper needs to inspire

Happy New Year? There wasn’t much to be happy about in the… Continue reading

Islanders’ support is meaningful

We would like offer our thanks to The Beachcomber for the article… Continue reading