LETTER: Primary system not representative

Does our top-two primary in Washington State give us what we want? We want to vote in an open primary with the right to vote for the person instead of the party. We also want majority rule to give us a representative democracy. Our “top-two primary” satisfies the first wish but not the second.

We now have a problem with our 34th Legislative District Senate primary on Aug. 7. Our current senator, Sharon Nelson, is not running for re-election. Eleven candidates have filed to run for Sharon’s seat: seven Democrats, two Republicans, one Independent and one “no party” candidate.

In 2016 Andrew Pilloud (Republican) received 20.25 percent of the vote to 79.75 percent for Joe Fitzgibbon (Democrat) in the race for 34th District House, Position 2.

In our current senate race, if the two Republicans each receive 10 percent of the vote, the remaining 80 percent will be split among the other nine candidates. This is an average of 8.89 percent for each of those nine candidates (not enough to win if they closely divide the vote). The 34th District — one of the most progressive districts in the state — could put two Republicans in the general election and no Democrats. Is this majority rule democracy?

There are at least three ways to combat the negative effects of this undemocratic plurality “top two” primary.

1) Find two or three Democrats willing to drop out of the race.

2) Ask the 34th District Democrats to endorse no more than two or three Democrats — also ask other progressive organizations to endorse the same Democrats.

3) Work for a future with an open, majority-rule election primary, such as ranked-choice voting (like Maine). With ranked-choice voting, no gaming of the election system is possible, and this aberration could never happen. See FairVote.org.

— Melvin Mackey

More in Letters to the Editor

Food bank benefits from fruit stand owner

Without exception, the East West Produce stand has donated unsold fruits and… Continue reading

VYFS seeks support

Vashon Youth & Family Services is the quiet foundation supporting many lives… Continue reading

Kids: Pick up a free light and wear it

Lots of kids are off to school before the sun gets up… Continue reading

Proposed refinery in Kalama should not be built

The final environmental impact statement for the world’s largest fracked gas and… Continue reading

Volunteering with nature center imparts important lessons

About a month ago the Vashon Nature Center put out a call… Continue reading

Beachcomber’s VCA coverage has been thoughtful

I want to commend The Beachcomber for its thoughtful coverage of Kevin… Continue reading

Tacoma plant poses large risks for Salish Sea

Thanks to Maia Syfers for her article on Puget Sound Energy’s plan… Continue reading

Make your mailboxes colorful

Every summer as I drive around the island, I see lines of… Continue reading

Hospital district is solution to island’s health care problems

Hospital district There is solution to island’s health care problems This October,… Continue reading

Downsizing: Let’s try new approach to auctions

After a lifetime of accumulating, most of my generation is intent on… Continue reading

Donations to church will go to good cause

A big shout out to the folks who parked their cars and… Continue reading

Changing Vashon: New eateries are for the affluent

I applaud the success of “Destination Vashon.” Mission accomplished. You have created… Continue reading